I started to play the new Tomb Raider recently and as I already
knew the first hour or so is a series of non-ending QTEs. And as I already knew
too, the brand new Lara Croft is represented as vulnerable and terrified as opposed
to our usual invincible arrogant hero. What I didn’t know, though (but should
have guessed), is that these two elements are quite contradictory: simply put, a
hand-holding, heavily scripted, QTEfest’s tutorial does not convey, at all,
vulnerability and terror. There was not one moment during that whole sequence
where I felt vulnerable because everything was so scripted and pre-determined that
nothing seemed threatening. At least not to me as a player: I was watching a
vulnerable character, yes, but I sure wasn’t playing one. In fact, the few
moments I was playing, in control of Lara, I was just like the usual invincible
confident hero I played before in every other third-person action game – I
mean, how can I fail at pressing W? I know where the W key is after all. Pressing
W for half-an-hour can feel meaningful when playing Proteus, because this minimalism suits the contemplative experience
the game offers, but it doesn’t work as well when you’re running to get out of
a cave which is falling around you: the triviality and impossible-to-fail
action of pressing W just doesn’t match the representation of chaos and
imminent threat on the screen.

The opening sequence
of Tomb Raider (the first twenty
minutes in particular) is as bad a case of ludonarrative dissonance as it can
get, cramming in as few minutes as possible all the biggest problems with how
AAA videogames envision interactive storytelling nowadays, which is a bit sad
because the intentions were good (I want to play a vulnerable character for a
change) and the writing is above average, for the most part, so let’s honor
this eloquent case study by taking it apart.